The Democratic Party thought it had avoided a huge beating when they held the Senate on November 2nd. The firewall the DSCC built against a Republican Senate was mostly due to the meddling of Tea Party groups and a favourable mix of Democratic and Republican incumbents up for election. Neither of these factors is going to help them over the next two years. It is likely the Senate is going to be hardly recognisable as the body in which the Democrats hold a majority.
Even though 2012 is going to be the year President Obama (presumably) is on the ballot, there is little chance Democrats are taking their seats for granted. There are a total of 23 Democratic seats up for re-election (including independents) versus only ten Republicans. Not only are there more Democratic seats up for grabs, but they are also seats deep in red territory. Democrats such as Ben Nelson (D-NE), Kent Conrad (D-ND) and Joe Manchin (D-WV) are all conservative Democrats who will do everything they can to run against a president unpopular in their respective states. They will likely buck their party at every opportunity.
Many would counter by saying many Democrats from states such as Virginia and Missouri would tend to vote with the President more often because many young voters will be present during the Presidential contest. This is all but certain, however, as the electoral map is looking very different than in 2008 and core parts of Mr. Obama's base have been demoralised.
2012 is also an interesting year in which many of the prominent moderate Republican senators are up for re-election. Senators Scott Brown (R-MA), Olympia Snowe (R-ME) and Richard Luger (R-IN) will all face the prospect of running as a Republican in states Obama will likely carry. You may argue about Indiana, but this is definitely the case with New England. This will likely cause them to vote against their party. However, this automatically disqualifies them for winning their primary. This often trumps considerations for the general election (see Arlen Specter) and they will probably try to win their primary despite their past voting records.
All of these factors mean the Senate will be far more conservative than its partisan composition suggests. It is likely a good idea President Obama postponed debate over the Bush tax cuts until 2012, when Senators will have an incentive to make smart decisions.
Showing posts with label senate. Show all posts
Showing posts with label senate. Show all posts
Sunday, November 14, 2010
Wednesday, September 29, 2010
Senate elections matter... for House Democrats
There has been growing consensus among both liberals and conservatives that the Senate is more important than it used to be. In the last two decades, the filibuster and secret holds have been abused to the dismay of many a ruling party. This did not used to be a problem, though in the 111th Congress, it was a major consideration in most major pieces of legislation. This is the main reason why most of the attention this election cycle has gone to the Senate.
There is a more important reason, however, why Senate elections truly matter this year. With no presidential candidate up for election during the midterms, Senate candidates often appear at the top of the ballot. Senate candidates have the rare opportunity to bring out voters from all over the state, something that is not possible for individual House races. Therefore, good turnout for a Senate candidate means good turnout for all the House races in the state for that candidate's party.
Lets take a look. In Pennsylvania, Joe Sestak (D-PA) is running against former Rep. Pat Toomey (R-PA) for the seat of Arlen Specter (D-PA). Joe Sestak, though a strong candidate, has been having difficulty making headway in a strong anti-Democratic year. The RCP poll average for the race has Pat Toomey winning by 6.5%. Similarly, Nate Silver has a 92% chance of a Republican takeover. Pennsylvania has many swing districts held by vulnerable Democrats who will not be benefiting from a strong Democratic wave this year. I will list the key races below:
PA-03: R+6
PA-10: R+14
PA-11: R+11
PA-12: R+4
Notice there are no Republican seats in play. Some would argue Jim Gerlach (R-PA) is endangered, but I do not believe he will loose. Among the incumbents above, several have been in the House for more than two terms. Now lets take a look at a state which the Democrat is running an effective campaign. In Washington State, Incumbent Senator Patty Murray (D-WA) is fending off a challenge from perennial Republican candidate Dino Rossi. The RCP poll average for the race has Murray winning by 5.3%. Lets now look at the key House races.
WA-02: R+4
WA-03: R+9
WA-08: R+13
WA-09: D+3
Washington and Pennsylvania are relatively comparable states, when it comes to partisan identification. Both are strongly Democratic, but have many swing districts in the more rural areas. The four most likely to flip districts in Pennsylvania all lean or are Republican blowouts, and all controlled by Democrats. The Washington situation is somewhat different. Dave Reichert (R-WA) is vulnerable to the Democrats even in a bad year and the close Democratic races are all close to the margin of error.
There is also a similar effect of Governor's races on those down ballot, though it is not as clear as their Senate counterparts. Many governors have cross-party appeal and make turnout for House candidates much less reliable. If the Democrats want to hold on to their majority in the House of Representatives, they should start by looking to shore up of their winnable Senate races.
Tuesday, July 13, 2010
Scott Brown (R-MA) to vote yes on Wall Street Reform: passage all but assured
Scott Brown (R-MA) has announced today he will be supporting the financial reform bill being debated in the Senate. He came to this decision after having extracted concessions in conference committee, notably the removal of the $19 billion bank tax which would have affected many Boston banks. His vote will be joined by Senate moderates Olympia Snowe (R-ME) and Susan Collins (R-ME). The vote of conservative Iowa Senator Chuck Grassley will not be known until the cloture vote, though it is likely to be no. This bill has not been followed by the progressive community with the same intensity as the health care bill but it is a very big deal. It begins to reverse the trend of financial deregulation begun under President Reagan in a powerful way. It does not solve some of the problems which led to the financial meltdown, but does rein in some of the worst abuses by banks. It also shows there is still potential for negotiation with moderate Republicans, such as Scott Brown. This will likely hurt his standing among conservative Republicans, however.
Wednesday, July 7, 2010
Recess appointments are far from ideal, but definately warranted at this point
The Obama Administration has finally realized it has to do something about Republican holds on nominees in the Senate. This week, President Obama appointed Dr. Donald Berwick to be the head of the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) through a recess appointment. The recess appointment is a controversial process by which a President bypasses Congress in appointing federal officials to a half-term (2 years) during a Congressional recess.
Since being elected, President Obama has faced record numbers of holds on his nominees. This leaves the federal government without the staff and leadership it needs to carry out its duties. Senator Richard Shelby (R-AL) made headlines this year when he held hostage all federal nominations for pet projects back home. He eventually agreed to release the hold, though many of these nominees have yet to be confirmed.
Now, The Hill is reporting Mitch McConnell (R-KY) has blasted the Obama Administration for doing a recess appointment. His opposition mainly has to do with a single quote Berwick made about health care rationing in the past. What is really "truly outraging" is not the recess appointments, but the obstruction the Republicans are engaging in. You cannot blame the government for failing to stimulate the economy when you deprive them of the people needed to carry out the law.
Since being elected, President Obama has faced record numbers of holds on his nominees. This leaves the federal government without the staff and leadership it needs to carry out its duties. Senator Richard Shelby (R-AL) made headlines this year when he held hostage all federal nominations for pet projects back home. He eventually agreed to release the hold, though many of these nominees have yet to be confirmed.
Now, The Hill is reporting Mitch McConnell (R-KY) has blasted the Obama Administration for doing a recess appointment. His opposition mainly has to do with a single quote Berwick made about health care rationing in the past. What is really "truly outraging" is not the recess appointments, but the obstruction the Republicans are engaging in. You cannot blame the government for failing to stimulate the economy when you deprive them of the people needed to carry out the law.
Labels:
Barack Obama,
Mitch McConnell,
Recess appointments,
senate
Thursday, April 1, 2010
A take on Bob Corker and Lindsay Graham
There has been a unified chorus of discontent with the ongoing negotiations between Chris Dodd and Bob Corker on the financial regulation bill; and between Lindsay Graham, Joe Lieberman and John Kerry on climate change. The left has characterized both respective battles as a waste of energy on a process that substantially weakens important legislation while the right has accused the two senators of being RINOs (Republicans in Name Only). These adverse reactions to bipartisanship on both sides of the political spectrum only reinforce the polarized times we live in. I think both of these assertions miss their mark, especially in a bipartisan institution such as the senate.
The senate is known to be where bipartisan deals are struck, as the minority wields the power to obstruct, which is absent in the house. This is not to say that the power to obstruct hasn't been overwhelmingly abused recently, but it does have a purpose. This is where the art of compromise has been forgotten. The conservative GOP primary electorate is so bent on opposing Obama's agenda that politicians have no ability to negotiate on important issues. Legislators have forgotten that compromise means "a settlement of differences by mutual concessions." Lindsay Graham and Bob Corker (and to a lesser extent Olympia Snowe) therefore are possiby the last republican negotiators in the senate. They just happen to be very conservative senators, and their concessions must be correspondingly deep. If the GOP's more liberal senators (Judd Gregg, Olympia Snowe, Scott Brown and Susan Collins) negotiated in good faith on these issues, their concessions would not gain the ire of liberals in the same way.
Sadly, this is how partisan congress has become. We can only hope that more senators will follow these two in fulfilling the senate's role in government.
The senate is known to be where bipartisan deals are struck, as the minority wields the power to obstruct, which is absent in the house. This is not to say that the power to obstruct hasn't been overwhelmingly abused recently, but it does have a purpose. This is where the art of compromise has been forgotten. The conservative GOP primary electorate is so bent on opposing Obama's agenda that politicians have no ability to negotiate on important issues. Legislators have forgotten that compromise means "a settlement of differences by mutual concessions." Lindsay Graham and Bob Corker (and to a lesser extent Olympia Snowe) therefore are possiby the last republican negotiators in the senate. They just happen to be very conservative senators, and their concessions must be correspondingly deep. If the GOP's more liberal senators (Judd Gregg, Olympia Snowe, Scott Brown and Susan Collins) negotiated in good faith on these issues, their concessions would not gain the ire of liberals in the same way.
Sadly, this is how partisan congress has become. We can only hope that more senators will follow these two in fulfilling the senate's role in government.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)